Сriminal Law Protection of the Autonomy of Patients in Ukraine. Part 1

Sofiya Likhova, Marek Mozgawa

Abstract


The article aims to analyze the phenomenon of “patient’s autonomy” as an object of criminal law protection. Patients’ autonomy is one of the most important rights. Respect for it is one of the factors ensuring the correct treatment process. The article is divided into two parts. In this part, the authors analyze the legal acts of Ukraine, which regulate the process of providing medical services and guarantee patients’ right to autonomy. The authors discuss, i.a., the issue of the patient’s consent to medical interventions or the right to information about his or her state of health. They also point to statistics on offences committed by medical staff members in connection with their professional activities. Furthermore, they point out that the problem of violation of patient’s autonomy should be looked at not only from the legal but also from the social point of view. This applies to the patient–medical relationship, in which the doctor plays a leading role. Moreover, the content of these relations lies not only on the professional but also on the bioethical level.


Keywords


patient; patient’s autonomy; treatment process; violation of patient’s autonomy; doctor; criminal law protection

Full Text:

PDF

References


LITERATURE

Berdichevskiy F.Y., Ugolovnaya otvetstvennost meditsinskogo personala za narusheniye professionalnykh obyazanostey, Moskva 1970.

Blinov A.G., Ucheniye ob ugolovno-pravovoy okhrane prav i svobod patsiyenta, Saratov 2014 (avtoref. diss. na soiskaniye nauch. stepeni d-ra yurid. nauk).

Chebotarova H.V., Kryminalno-pravovi problem transplantatsiyi orhaniv abo tkanyn lyudyny ta donorstva, Kyyiv 2003 (dys. kand. yuryd. nauk.).

Didkivska H.V., Kryminolohichna kharakterystyka pravovoho zabezpechennya vzayemodiy i mizhnarodnykh system zapobihannya zlochynnosti, “Pravo ta derzhavne upravlinnya” 2019, no. 1(34).

Dorogin D.A., Protivopravnyye deyaniya, svyazannyye s organami i (ili) tkanyami cheloveka: ugolovno-pravovoye issledovaniye, Moskva 2016.

Drgonets Y.A., Khollender P., Sovremennaya meditsina I pravo; per. so slovats, Moskva 1991.

Dudorov O.O., [in:] Naukovo-praktychnyy komentar do Kryminalnoho kodeksu Ukrayiny, eds. M.I. Melnyk, M.I. Khavronyuk, Kyyiv 2009.

Dzhuzha O.M., Tychyna D.M., Chy isnuye henetychna skhylnist osoby do vchynennya kryminalnoho pravoporushennya?, “Pravovyy chasopys Donbasu” 2020, no. 1(70).

Gural L.O., Stanovlennya ta istorychna obumovlenist vidpovidalnosti za zapodiyannya tilesnykh ushkodzhen v ukrayinskomu kryminalomu pravi, “Nashe pravo” 2016, no. 2.

Hrytchuk Y.S., Pavlychko Y.M., Hrytchuk Y.M., Rol likarya u vynyknenni yatrohennykh zakhvoryuvan, “Medytsyna zaliznychnoho transportu Ukrayiny” 2004, no. 2.

Knysh S.V., Yurydychna vidpovidalnist za pravoporushennya u sferi okhorony zdoroya v Ukrayini, “Pravo i Bezpeka” 2018, no. 4(71).

Krylova N.E., Uholovnaya otvet·stvennost za prynuzhdenyya k donorstvu orhanov y tkaney cheloveka po zakonodatelstvu Rossyy ta Ukrayny, “Vestnyk Moskovskoho unyversyteta. Seryya Pravo” 2004, no. 5.

Maleina M.I., Zashchita lichnykh neimushchestvennykh prav sovetskikh grazhdan, Moskva 1991.

Myslyva O.O., Kryminalno-pravova kharakterystyka ta zapobihannya nezakonniy diyalnosti u sferi transplantatsiyi, Dnipropetrovsk 2011 (avtoref. dys. na zdobuttya nauk. stupenya kand. yuryd. nauk).

Napalkova I.G., Formalno-yuridicheskiy metod kak osnova metodologii yuridicheskogo pozitivizma, “Filosofiya prava” 2018, no. 3(86).

Naukovo-praktychnyy komentar do Kryminalnoho kodeksu Ukrayiny, eds. M.I. Melnyk, M.I. Khavronyuk, Kyyiv 2012.

Panov N.I., Sposob soversheniya prestupleniya i ugolovnaya otvetstvennost, Kharkov 1982.

Ponomarev A.B., Metodologiya nauchnykh issledovaniy: ucheb. Posobiye, Perm 2014.

Samorodov V.N., Metodologicheskiye osnovaniya sovremennoy yuridicheskoy nauki: postanovka problemy, “Vestnik MGTU” 2014, vol. 17(4).

Shulha V., Stavlennya ta rozvytok derzhavnoho rehulyuvannya transplantatsiyi v Ukrayini, “Visnyk Natsionalnoyi akademiyi derzhavnoho upravlinnya pry Prezydentovi Ukrayiny” 2012, no. 1.

Sirenko O.V., Povedinka poterpiloho yak skladova yoho kryminalistychnoyi kharakterystyky, “Mizhnarodnyy yurydychnyy visnyk: zbirnyk Natsionalnoho uniwersytetu derzhavnoyi podatkovoyi sluzhby Ukrayiny” 2015, no. 1(2).

Sopilko I.N., Likhovaya S.Y., Uvarova N.V., Novaya sushchnost i vidovoye deleniye ugolovnykh pravonarusheniy i otvetstvennosti, “Vserossiyskiy kriminologicheskiy zhurnal” 2018, vol. 12(6).

Stetsenko S.G., [in:] Medychne pravo Ukrayiny: pidruchnyk, eds. S.G. Stetsenko, V.Y. Stetsenko, I.Y. Senyuta, Kyyiv 2008.

Stetsenko S.G., [in:] Medychne pravo Ukrayiny (realizatsiya ta zakhyst prav patsiyentiv), eds. S. G. Stetsenko, V.O. Halay, Kyyiv 2010.

Tao Lai Po-Wah J., A Confucian Approach to a “Shared Family Decision Model” in Health Care: Reflections on Moral Pluralism, [in:] Global Bioethics: The Collapse of Consensus, ed. H. Tristram Engelhardt, Houston 2006.

Tikhomirov A.D., Sravnitelnoye pravovedeniye: metodologicheskiye problem komparativnoy samorefleksii v ukrainskoy interpretatsii, “Vestnik Universiteta imeni O.Ye. Kutafina (MGYUA)” 2016, no. 3.

Varchuk T.V., Viktimologicheskiye modelirovaniye v kriminologii i praktike preduprezhdeniya prestupnosti, Moskva 2012.

Yegorova O.A., Funktsii istoricheskikh i logicheskikh metodov v yuridicheskom poznanii, “Vestnik Yuzhno-Uralskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya Pravo” 2016, vol. 16(2).

Yegorova O.A., K voprosu o roli logicheskikh sredstv I metodov v yuridicheskom poznanii i deyatelnosti, “Vestnik Yuzhno-Uralskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya Pravo” 2013, vol. 13(4).

Zherzh L.A., Zakonodatelnoye regulirovaniye ugolovno otvetstvennosti za nezakonnuyu transplantatsiyu: istoriko-pravovoy analiz, “Legea Şi Viaţa” 2019, no. 1/2(325).

Zherzh L.A., Myronchuk K.V., Kharkovets Y.M., Pravovyy analiz “Prezumptsiy i zhody” ta “Prezumptsiyiy i nezhody” pry nezakonniy transplantatsiyi orhaniv abo tkanyn lyudyny, “Porivnyalno-analitychne pravo: elektronne naukove fakhove vydannya yurydychnoho fakultetu DVNZ Uzhhorodskyy natsionalnyy universytet” 2017, no. 6.

Zherzh L.A., Rozmayita V.V., Determinanty koruptsiyi u diyalnosti medychnykh pratsivnykiv. Fiskalna polityka: teoretychni ta praktychni aspekty yurydychnoyi nauky: zbirnyk tez dopovidey II Mizhnarodnoyi naukovo-praktychnoyi konferentsiyi (23 lystopada 2018 roku), Irpin 2018.

Zherzh L.A., Rozmayita V.V., Ponyattya kryminalnoyi vidpovidalnosti medychnykh pratsivnykiv za vchynennya profesiynykh zlochyniv ta yiyi osoblyvosti. II Vseukrayinski naukovo-pravovi chytannya pamyati doktora yurydychnykh nauk, profesora, zasluzhenoho yurysta Ukrayiny, chlen-korespondenta Natsionalnoyi akademiyi pravovykh nauk Ukrayiny Niny Romanivny Nyzhnyk: zb. materialiv, Irpin 2018.

ONLINE SOURCES

Medreforma: k kakim vracham mozhno popast bez napravleniya, 11.01.2020, https://nostalji102fm.com.ua/news/ukraina/30002-medreforma-k-kakim-vracham-mozhno-popast-bez-napravlenija [access: 21.08.2021].

Medreforma v Ukraine: Minzdrav nedovolen vtorym etapom i gotovit korennyye izmeneniya, 13.04.2020, https://tsn.ua/ru/ukrayina/medreforma-v-ukraine-minzdrav-nedovolen-vtorym-etapom-i-gotovit-korennye-izmeneniya-1538127.html [access: 12.09.2021].

Medreforma v Ukraine: spisok platnykh i besplatnykh meditsinskikh uslug, 6.01.2020, https://aif.ua/health/medreforma_v_ukraine_spisok_platnyh_i_besplatnyh_medicinskih_uslug [access: 28.09.2021].

Meshcheryakova T.V., Avtonomiya patsiyenta: natsionalnoye v globalnom kontekste, “Vestnik tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta” 2011, no. 3, https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/avtonomiya-patsienta-natsionalnoe-v-globalnom-kontekste/viewer [access: 28.09.2021].

Pismo Ministerstva yustitsii Ukrainy “Otvetstvennost meditsinskikh rabotnikov”, 26.06.2011, www.medlawcenter.com.ua/ru/105/490.html [access: 20.06.2021].

LEGAL ACTS

Constitution of Ukraine of 28 June 1996 (Vidomosti Verkhovnoyi Rady Ukrayiny 1996, no. 30, p. 141), http://zakon2.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/254к/96-вр [access: 10.07.2021].

Zakon Ukrayiny, Osnovy zakonodavstva Ukrayiny pro okhoronu zdorovya, no. 2801-XII (Vidomosti Verkhovnoyi Rady Ukrayiny 1993, no. 4, p. 19), https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2801-12#Text [access: 10.06.2021].

Zakon Ukrayiny, Pro zakhyst naselennya vid infektsiynykh khvorob, no. 1645-III (Vidomosti Verkhovnoyi Rady Ukrayiny 2000, no. 29, p. 228), https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1645-14#Text [access: 21.06.2021].




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17951/sil.2021.30.4.373-391
Date of publication: 2021-10-13 00:45:50
Date of submission: 2020-12-23 13:39:15


Statistics


Total abstract view - 1113
Downloads (from 2020-06-17) - PDF - 0

Indicators



Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2021 Sofiya Likhova, Marek Mozgawa

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.